Swing Feel vs. Swing Thoughts?
SWING FEEL vs SWING THOUGHT
Swing thoughts are very necessary for learning. They are not very effective for performing in competition. Golf swings that are the most effective in competition have been practiced into habit and function without conscious direction by the brain.
KEY: You will probably never play your best golf with anything that you have to remember to do. You just have to remember to practice until reminding yourself of what to do is no longer necessary.
The following is from Readings in Motor Learning by Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia, PA. Learning in Sports, Physiology of Motor Learning.
“…..willed movements which are new and unfamiliar always require conscious thought. They are performed at first with more or less conscious attention to the details of their execution. Once mastered, they operate automatically. Conscious introspection at this stage may even disrupt the effectiveness of an established pattern. After an act has become automatic, it is less well performed if it must first be considered and analyzed.”
Implication. Conscious attention to details of an automated action will reduce the efficiency/economy of that action. There is a time BEFORE a contest when conscious attention to details of technique at practice need to cease so that preparation can be perceived by an athlete as consisting of “good feeling” techniques that are performed automatically.
Application. Signals from the brain (thoughts) stimulate muscle activity (movements) which in turn stimulate a kinesthetic awareness (feel) that accompanies the (movements).
Once “what it feels like” is established, the (feel) can be used to recreate the (movements) without (thought). This allows the desired movements to become automatic and automatic movements are much more dependable under the stress of competition.
Hank Johnson, PGA
September 8, 2008
